The Metafilter Infodump (panel talk from AoIR 12)

This is the script of a talk I gave in early October this year, at the Association of Internet Research’s twelfth annual conference. I was one of four Metafilter members presenting different research-related talks about Metafilter as a site and a community. The other panelists were Kim Witten, Kris Markman, and Quinn Warnick. You can find their respective presentation notes here: Quinn, Kris, Kim.

I was the first of the four to present, and so opened with a short intro about the site itself before moving on to a discussion of the Metafilter Infodump, a weekly-updated repository of site activity data on which this talk is focused.

This was originally a slideshow presentation, but my slides weren’t anything special so I’ve left most of those out of this re-run of the talk’s presentation in favor of running the text itself. If this reads a bit odd in spots, it’s partly a reflection of that transition.

The Infodump
Continue reading

Overthanking a plate of injokes

So I’ve been playing Glitch for the last few days; it’s a lightweight free-to-play social MMO done as a browser Flash game, sort of a cross between a platformer and combat-free resource-wrangling games like Animal Crossing. It’s a good little time. It looks a bit like this:

But I play a lot of games and don’t mention it here much at all, so why am I bringing up this one? Because of a plate of beans, is why.

It goes like this:

1. I found out about Glitch because I work for and hang out at Metafilter, and a lot of folks on Metafilter are playing it. And so while my little yellow dude has been mining beryl and cavorting with pigs in exchange for steaks and harvesting bubbles off of bubble trees, I’ve been chatting with my fellow Mefites. And not only are the are a lot of us playing the game, there’s even a couple folks who work for Tiny Speck, the company that makes Glitch.

2. There’s a long-running joke on Metafilter about how we’re the kind of people who could overthink a plate of beans. It started as a joke someone made during a thread years ago in which people were earnestly deconstructing the performative elements of Alanis Morissette’s cover of Black Eyed Peas’ My Humps, and it caught on, to the point where “beanplating” and “to beanplate” are a commonly understood derived verb forms used to describe maybe-needlessly-in-depth analysis of one thing or another. There’s even a song.

3. Glitch has bean trees, on which grow beans. One can harvest beans, and eat them or use them as constituents in recipes. What Glitch hasn’t had is beans arranged tastefully on a plate.

4. Except, well, that now exists, thanks to one of those Mefite Glitchers who happens to work on the game.

Here it is:

Click on it and you get, as with most items in Glitch, a context menu that gives you some basic options and a special option unique to this item: overthinking.
Continue reading

The Big Atreides (or, The Dune Abides)

So there was a brief discussion of a twofer of Dune-related posts over on Metatalk, and it quickly unraveled into a series of questionable Frank Herbert vs. The Coen Brothers jokes when Metafilter user Eideteker said:

The Dune Abides.

You can read through the thread to see the raw output as folks put it together. Fun real-time riffing, people pushing in a few different directions with it over a couple of hours.

Here’s a neatened-up arrangement of my take on it, in the general style of an IMDB “Memorable Quotes” digest:

The Big Atreides

PRINCESS IRULAN [voiceover]: Way out in the stars there was this fella… fella I wanna tell ya about. Fella by the name of Paul Atreides. At least that was the handle his loving parents gave him, but he never had much use for it himself. Mr. Atreides, he called himself “The Dib”. Now, “Dib” – that’s a name no one would self-apply where I come from. But then there was a lot about the Dib that didn’t make a whole lot of sense. And a lot about where he lived, likewise. But then again, maybe that’s why I found the world so darned interestin’.

They call Arrakis “the Spice planet”. I didn’t find it to be that, exactly. But I’ll allow there are some colorful folks there. ‘Course I can’t say I’ve seen Caladan, and I ain’t never been to Ix. And I ain’t never seen no Reverend Mother in her damned undies, so the feller says. But I’ll tell you what – after seeing Dune, and this here story I’m about to unfold, well, I guess I seen a purpose every bit as turrible as you’d see on any of them other planets. And in Galach, too. So I can die with a smile on my face, without feelin’ like the God Emperor gypped me.

Now this here story I’m about to unfold took place back in the early 10190s – just about the time of the conflict with Vlad Harkonnen and the I-treides. I only mention it because sometimes there’s a man… I won’t say a madhi, ’cause, what’s a madhi? But sometimes, there’s a man. And I’m talkin’ about the Dib here. Sometimes, there’s a man, well, he’s the man for the place the Bene Gesserit dare not look. He fits right in there. And that’s the Dib, on Dune. And even if he’s a prescient man – and the Dib was most certainly that. Quite possibly the most prescient in Arakeen, which would place him high in the runnin’ for the most prophetic galaxywide. But sometimes there’s a man, sometimes, there’s a man. Aw. I lost my heighliner of thought here. But… aw, Shaitan. I’ve done introduced him enough.

THE DIB: I’m the Muad’dib. So that’s what you call me. You know, that or, uh, His ‘Dibeness, or uh, ‘Diber, or El Muad’diberino if you’re not into the whole my-name-is-a-killing-word thing.

THE DIB: Yeah, well, that’s just, like, my terrible purpose, man.

CHANI: What do you do for recreation?

THE DIB: Oh, the usual. I jihad. Ride worms around. The occasional prescient spice trance.

DUNCAN IDAHO: Facedancers! Fuck me. I mean, say what you like about the tenets of the Bene Gesserit, ‘Dib, at least it’s an ethos.

FEYD-RAUTHA [to THE DIB]: What’s this day of rest shit? What’s this wormshit? I don’t fuckin’ care! It don’t matter to Feyd. But you’re not foolin’ me, man. You might fool the fucks in the naib, but you don’t fool Feyd. This bush league wheels-within-wheels stuff. Laughable, man – ha ha! I would have killed you Saturday. I kill you next Wednesday instead. Wooo! You got a date Wednesday, baby!

THE DIB: Mind if I do a water of L?

STILGAR: You have got to buck up, man. You cannot drag this negative energy in to the jihad!

THE DIB: Fuck the jihad… Fuck YOU, Stilgar!

STILGAR: Fuck the jihad? All right, I can see you don’t want to be cheered up here, ‘Dib. Come on Guerney, let’s go get us a worm.

IRULAN [voiceover]: I guess that’s the way the whole durned Golden Path keeps perpetuatin’ itself.

CHANI: Do you like sex, Usul?

THE DIB: ‘Scuse me?

CHANI: Sex. The physical act of love. Coitus. Do you like it?

THE DIB: I was talking about the waters of my homeworld.

STILGAR: Jamis was a good fighter, and a good Freman. He was one of us. He was a man who loved the desert… and killing Harkonnens, and as a wormrider he explored the sands of the Great Flat, from Tuono Basin to Habbanya Ridge and… up to… Gara Kulon. He died, like so many young men of his generation, he died before his time. In your wisdom, Shai-Hulud, you took him, as you took so many bright flowering young men on Salusa Secundus, on Giedi Prime, on Bele Tegeuse. These young men gave their lives. And so would Jamis. Jamis, who loved fighting. And so, Jamis of Sietch Tabr, in accordance with what we think your dying wishes might well have been, we commit the water of your body to the tribe, which you loved so well. Good night, sweet prince.

THE DIB: Just say the Litany Against Fear, man.

STILGAR: I’m perfectly calm, ‘Dib.

THE DIB: Yeah, waving the fucking crysknife around?

STILGAR: Calmer than you are.

[The Baron Vladimir Harkonnen and his mentat aid Piter De Vries interrogate Duke Leto Atreides.]

VLADIMIR: Is this your uniform, Leto? Is this your uniform, Leto?

DE VRIES: Look, Baron…

VLADIMIR: Piter, please? Is this your uniform, Leto?

DE VRIES: Just ask him about the signet ring.

VLADIMIR: Is this yours, Leto? Is this your uniform, Leto?

DE VRIES: Is that your thopter out front?

VLADIMIR: Is this your uniform, Leto?

DE VRIES: We know it’s his fucking uniform! Where’s the fucking signet ring, you freaking’ duke?

VLADIMIR: Look, Leto. Have you ever heard of Giedi Prime?

DE VRIES: Oh, for CHOAM’s sake, Vlad…

VLADIMIR: You’re entering a world of pain, Duke. We know that this is your uniform. We know that you had a signet ring.

DE VRIES: And your fucking heir.

VLADIMIR: And your fucking heir. And, we know that this is your uniform.

DE VRIES: We’re going to feed you your uniform, Leto.

VLADIMIR: You’re killing your lady, Leto!

IRULAN: I like your style, ‘Dib.

THE DIB: Well, I dig your style too, man. Got the whole galactic princess thing goin’.

IRULAN: Thankee.

IRULAN [voiceover]: Sometimes you ride the worm and sometimes, well, he rides you.

Man oh man.

Nothing in like three months? I’ve been neglecting this more than I thought.

It’s been a busy, Metafilter-centric three months — after finishing up that trip (which was fantastic), we did a raffle (complete with wierd Paypal headache) that raised over $12K for charity, we ran an informal UI experiment with Metafilter favorites (complete with much arguing), Matt found out he had a great big pituitary tumor and scared the shit out of us, and said tumor has ended up responding very well to non-surgical treatment. Plus a dozen other slightly less landmark-worthy things I’m forgetting to mention.

And two mefites, newish member Bageena and long-timer and blogosphere-coiner Brad “bradlands” Graham, both passed away suddenly this last week. Sobering start to the new year.

I think I’m going to dodge the formal Resolutions thing again this year and just state a general intent to get my shit in gear.

Stupid Airline Tricks

So there it is: I’m going to spend a month flying around on Jetblue and visiting an unreasonably large number of my fellow Metafilter members.

Thanks to Jetblue’s stuntish (and sold-out-early) All-You-Can-Jet promotion, I’ll be spending the month from September 8th through October 8th flying around the continental United Stated, hitting a new city just about every other day and partying my ass off with mefites.

It’s an aggressive schedule; I’ve never done anything quite like this before. I’m excited and a little terrified, and I think it’ll be a hell of a lot of fun.

My city-by-city itinerary looks like this:

NYC
Boston
Portland, ME
Randolph, VT
New Orleans
Philly
Baltimore
DC
Raleigh/Durham
Las Vegas
LA
San Francisco
Salt Lake City
Chicago
Denver

I plan on documenting the trip heavily as I go, and I’ll be documenting the run-up to the 8th as well as I figure out how, exactly, I’m going to pull this thing off.

Happy Birthday, Metafilter

Metafilter turns ten years old today. There’s no site on the web I love more, and I couldn’t imagine a better place to work.

I celebrate by recycling, so here’s two (among several) songs I’ve written about the place over the years:

Happy [8th] Birthday, Metafilter, from a couple years back, and
Metafilter’s Down, from our long dark downtime of the soul earlier this year.

Metafilter: like a never-ending editorial meeting

In an age where websites are always hunting for the next great trick for keeping unruly commentors in line – voting mechanisms? User scores? Enforced real names? – MetaFilter seems to be held together by the sheer stubbornness of its culture.

From (mefi’s own) Ivor Tossell at the Globe & Mail, here’s one of the best short explanations of Metafilter I’ve yet read.

And I’m not just saying that because it quotes me.

An explantion of why there is a drawing of Lute Cat on the internet now

1. So one of the things I do at Metafilter is delete, for one reason another, a small portion of the posts that our users put up on the front page each day.

2. For example, this was a double post, and those are routinely removed — once something has had a shot on Metafilter, that’s pretty much it.

3. When we remove posts, we leave a deletion reason explaining to whatever degree with think is necessary what’s going on with the deletion, so that the poster and any curious readers have a little context for why the post went away.

4. (Posts that are deleted remain viewable at their original url, as in (2) above, but don’t show up to search engines or get listed in the site archives, etc.)

5. If the reason for deletion is pretty much self-explanatory and there’s nothing really at stake emotionally with the deletion (i.e. it’s not a contentious issue, no malicious intent on the poster’s part, no apparently newbie confusion, etc), I might provide a sillier or jokier reason than normal.

6. For example, again, the deletion reason in (2), where I went sort of meta-memetic, as such:

This post was deleted for the following reason: now we just need someone to combine this with that old tapestry-art meme and call it “thru thou” and the last track will be called “Play Him Hence, Lute Cat” and we’ll basically be all set. — cortex

7. Sometimes, people will read these deletion reasons and laugh to themselves and then that’s all that happens.

8. But sometimes, they will draw an awesome picture of Lute Cat.